| Paper Abstract and Keywords |
| Presentation |
2009-07-19 10:35
Does implicit grammatical person influence perspective in mental simulation? Manami Sato, Benjamin K. Bergen (Univ. of Hawaii) TL2009-21 |
| Abstract |
(in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| (in English) |
Language comprehension causes the retrieval of listeners prior perceptual and motor experiences, and this retrieval generates perceptual-motor simulations of the described scenes ([1], [2]). The internal mechanisms of mental simulation have been investigated in terms of (1) unit simulation size (single word vs. context) and (2) grammatical aspect. Processing an isolated word (e.g., 'calculator') activates intrinsic knowledge of the object (e.g., color, shape, and size) as well as related interactional knowledge ([3]). Contextual information, however, is able to override the object痴 intrinsic properties and dynamically produce contextually appropriate representations ([4]). Grammatical aspect, encoded in the progressive or perfect tense, generates simulations with different time-points for the event ([5]). Additionally, mental simulation adopts particular perspectives denoted by 1st and 3rd person subjects ([6], [7]). Contextual information along with grammatical aspect are the defining factors of simulation.
In the current studies on Japanese, we address three questions: 1) is the emergence of perspective language-dependent? (Experiment 1); 2) can elements of prior discourse drive listeners to adopt a perspective in the absence of an explicit subject? (Experiment 2); 3) what role do explicit perspective markers (i.e., subject pronouns) play in simulation?
Experiment 1: Japanese speakers read three sentences with explicit subject pronouns and decided if a depicted event was mentioned in the final sentence. The accompanying picture depicts the event from an internal (a performer痴 viewpoint) or external perspective (an observer痴 viewpoint). Twenty-four critical sentences and corresponding pairs of internal and external perspective pictures were created, and fully crossed to produce perspective matching and mismatching pictures for each item. The results agree with previous experiments in English ([6]) showing that responses were significantly faster when the picture matched the perspective implied by the pronoun - 2nd person facilitated internal perspective, while 3rd person facilitated external perspective (Fs>5). Experiment 2: Subject pronouns were removed from the third sentence (in Japanese, contextually retrievable subjects are omittable). Though the subjects were retrievable, the absent pronouns eliminated the compatibility effect seen in Experiment 1 (Fs<1).
The two experiments indicate that perspective is as robust a feature of mental simulation in Japanese as has been observed in English, and perspective in simulation is determined by the repetition of explicit perspective markers within each clause. Perspective as a feature of mental simulation situates language comprehenders at a particular vantage point, but decays quickly if not driven by the stream of discourse.
References:
[1] Barsalou, L. W. (1999). Perceptual symbol systems, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 577-660.
[2] Barsalou, L.W. (2008). Grounded cognition. Annual Review of Psychology, 59, 617-645.
[3] Masson, M., Bub, D., Warren, C. (2008). Kicking calculators: Contribution of embodied representations to sentence comprehension. Journal of Memory and Language 59, 259-265.
[4] Zwaan, R.A., Stanfield, R.A., and Yaxley, R.H. (2003). Do language comprehenders routinely represent the shapes of objects? Psychological Science, 13, 168-171.
[5] Madden, C. J. and Zwaan, R.A. (2003). How does verb aspect constrain event representations? Memory and Cognition, 31(5), 663-672.
[6] Brunye, T. T., Ditman, T., Mahoney, C.R., Augustyn, J.S., and Taylor, H.A. (In press). When you and I share perspectives: Pronouns modulate perspective taking during narrative comprehension. Psychological Science.
[7] Zwaan, R.A., Yaxley, C.J., and Aveyard, M.E. (2004). Moving words: Dynamic mental representations in language comprehension. Cognitive Science, 28, 611-619. |
| Keyword |
(in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| (in English) |
Perspective / Simulation / Discourse / Personal pronouns / language comprehension / Japanese / Null subject / |
| Reference Info. |
IEICE Tech. Rep., vol. 109, no. 140, TL2009-21, pp. 73-77, July 2009. |
| Paper # |
TL2009-21 |
| Date of Issue |
2009-07-11 (TL) |
| ISSN |
Print edition: ISSN 0913-5685 Online edition: ISSN 2432-6380 |
Copyright and reproduction |
All rights are reserved and no part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Notwithstanding, instructors are permitted to photocopy isolated articles for noncommercial classroom use without fee. (License No.: 10GA0019/12GB0052/13GB0056/17GB0034/18GB0034) |
| Download PDF |
TL2009-21 |
| Conference Information |
| Committee |
TL |
| Conference Date |
2009-07-18 - 2009-07-19 |
| Place (in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| Place (in English) |
New Century Plaza II, Hakozaki Campus of Kyushu Univ. |
| Topics (in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| Topics (in English) |
Processing and Learning of Human Language |
| Paper Information |
| Registration To |
TL |
| Conference Code |
2009-07-TL |
| Language |
English |
| Title (in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| Sub Title (in Japanese) |
(See Japanese page) |
| Title (in English) |
Does implicit grammatical person influence perspective in mental simulation? |
| Sub Title (in English) |
|
| Keyword(1) |
Perspective |
| Keyword(2) |
Simulation |
| Keyword(3) |
Discourse |
| Keyword(4) |
Personal pronouns |
| Keyword(5) |
language comprehension |
| Keyword(6) |
Japanese |
| Keyword(7) |
Null subject |
| Keyword(8) |
|
| 1st Author's Name |
Manami Sato |
| 1st Author's Affiliation |
University of Hawaii, Manoa (Univ. of Hawaii) |
| 2nd Author's Name |
Benjamin K. Bergen |
| 2nd Author's Affiliation |
University of Hawaii, Manoa (Univ. of Hawaii) |
| 3rd Author's Name |
|
| 3rd Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 4th Author's Name |
|
| 4th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 5th Author's Name |
|
| 5th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 6th Author's Name |
|
| 6th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 7th Author's Name |
|
| 7th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 8th Author's Name |
|
| 8th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 9th Author's Name |
|
| 9th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 10th Author's Name |
|
| 10th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 11th Author's Name |
|
| 11th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 12th Author's Name |
|
| 12th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 13th Author's Name |
|
| 13th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 14th Author's Name |
|
| 14th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 15th Author's Name |
|
| 15th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 16th Author's Name |
|
| 16th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 17th Author's Name |
|
| 17th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 18th Author's Name |
|
| 18th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 19th Author's Name |
|
| 19th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 20th Author's Name |
|
| 20th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 21st Author's Name |
|
| 21st Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 22nd Author's Name |
|
| 22nd Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 23rd Author's Name |
|
| 23rd Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 24th Author's Name |
|
| 24th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 25th Author's Name |
|
| 25th Author's Affiliation |
() |
| 26th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 26th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 27th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 27th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 28th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 28th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 29th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 29th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 30th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 30th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 31st Author's Name |
/ / |
| 31st Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 32nd Author's Name |
/ / |
| 32nd Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 33rd Author's Name |
/ / |
| 33rd Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 34th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 34th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 35th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 35th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| 36th Author's Name |
/ / |
| 36th Author's Affiliation |
()
() |
| Speaker |
Author-1 |
| Date Time |
2009-07-19 10:35:00 |
| Presentation Time |
35 minutes |
| Registration for |
TL |
| Paper # |
TL2009-21 |
| Volume (vol) |
vol.109 |
| Number (no) |
no.140 |
| Page |
pp.73-77 |
| #Pages |
5 |
| Date of Issue |
2009-07-11 (TL) |
|